Irving Eyster
Irving R. Eyster: Keys historian/archaeologist.
He taught archaeology at FIU and University of Miami;
anthropology at Miami-Dade Community College and was a Dade County
archaeologist for two years. He is a member of the Society of
Professional Archaeologists and served on the Historic Florida
Keys Preservation Board for 16 years. He is president of Matecumbe
Historical Board.
His books include: Indian Key, Handbook of South Florida Archaeology,
and Islamorada and More.
Henry
M. Flagler determined that the Florida
East Coast Railway would build the Key West Extension from
Miami to the island city (see article on The Overseas Railway).
By 1904, the track was completed to Homestead, then went rapidly
through the upper Keys. Progress was slower at Long Key, but the
railway reached Marathon in early 1908. The Florida East Coast
Railway built a terminal at the end of a 2,860 foot dock that
extended into the ocean to the west of Knight’s Key. This enabled
the P&O Steamship line to commence service in February, 1908.
At this time Pigeon Key was selected by Resident
Engineer C.S. Coe as a good site to build a work camp for the
bridge builders. He directed the construction of a small community
on the 5-acre island, with a dock, warehouse, materials yard,
kitchen and dining hall, four dormitories, a construction headquarters,
and a tent city to house the great number of workers on the island.
At times there were as many as 400 men living at the camp. Each
dormitory building had a reading room with lights supplied by
a generator, and comfortable mattresses on double bunk beds, with
plenty of clean bed clothes. All laundry was done by the company.
The engineering and office staff were housed in a combination
office and sleeping quarters.
Additional laborers were housed in the tents. These
tents were built on wooden frameworks and numbered as houses in
a city. Many of the workers were from New York, and were termed
"Bos," a shortened form of the word "hobo." The spaces between
the rows of tents were given street names from New York, such
as Broadway, Fifth Avenue and 32nd Street. Food was wholesome,
with menus of beefsteak, beef roast and Mulligan stew. Ham, bacon
and fish were served with beans, peas, sweet and Irish potatoes,
pumpkins, tomatoes and apples.
Cleanliness was enforced on Pigeon Key...all debris
was thrown into the sea where it was washed away. Outhouses on
docks served as latrines. On the island, walks were laid out edged
with short walls of coral rock and conch shells. Several flower
gardens were maintained on the island.
After the railway was completed in 1912, Pigeon
Key became the headquarters for the work crews who maintained
the Seven-Mile Bridge and the bridge tenders who operated the
draw span over Moser Channel. Most of the temporary construction
buildings were dismantled, and a new generation of buildings were
erected to house the maintenance people and their families. The
island became a small village with a store, post office, school
house, shop, dock, storage buildings, homes for the foremen of
the section crew and the paint gang foreman, and also houses for
the bridge tender and assistant bridge tender. There was separate
housing for Negro workers.
The painting crew had an enormous job, working
almost all year on the Seven-Mile Bridge and also the Bahia Honda
Bridge. These were the only bridges in the world where the tracks,
plates, girders and even the spikes were painted — a necessary
protective measure against corrosion from the salt air of the
Keys. The crews would start at the Marathon end of the bridge,
paint to the western end, then move on to the Bahia Honda Bridge.
By this time they finished at Bahia Honda, the east end of the
Seven-Mile Bridge would need painting again.
Pigeon Key was the only village on the Keys at
this time without a cistern. Fresh water was delivered from the
mainland by train. Water cars with 3,500 gallon wooden tanks stopped
above the island on the Seven-Mile Bridge and transferred the
water to similar tanks on the ground below the tracks.
The island had a typical one-room school house
for the children who lived there. The teachers came from Key West
and boarded on the island. The school had 12 grades; sometimes
there was only one student in each class. The bell on the roof
of the schoolhouse came from a train engine. Photos show that
there was a sand pile beside the school, a pole with an American
flag, and a "Quiet-School Zone" sign next to the building. The
children of the island had a playhouse under the tracks, and a
swing hung from the trestle above for their enjoyment. Most of
the children left in the summer to visit relatives.
Pigeon Key was described as "a child’s paradise"
by Esther Hines Diver, who lived on the island from the time she
was 5 until age 17. She tells that water was piped into the houses,
but there were no bathrooms; restrooms and showers were over the
water by the school. At the time there was only one telephone
on the island, used by all the residents for business and emergencies.
The cook for the workers was a large black man
named Henry, well over six feet tall. He was respected by all
the workers because of his size and because he was a good cook.
No alcohol was permitted on Pigeon Key; if an occasional bottle
was smuggled in, Henry confiscated it and destroyed the booze.
Black and white residents had separate houses and buildings, and
no women or children were allowed in the Negro quarters.
Pigeon Key functioned as a F.E.C.
Ry. maintenance center until the 1935
Labor Day hurricane destroyed the track and fill in the lower
Matecumbe area. Pigeon Key suffered little damage, but there are
stories that the residents used mattresses and furniture to block
the windows and doors. As a result of the hurricane, the F.E.C.
Ry. sold the bridges and right-of-way from Florida City to
Key West to the state for $640,000.
A new era began on Pigeon Key as the train bridges
were converted into roads for the Overseas Highway. This took
three years to complete. On March 29, 1938, Key West Mayor William
Albury led a motorcade to Pigeon Key to meet other dignitaries
for the opening of the bridge. The daughter of the Cuban Council,
Senorita Ida Rodrigues, cut the ribbon while newsreel cameramen
and reporters took pictures. Pigeon Key was now on the route to
Key West, but automobiles could not drive onto the island until
the end of 1938, when the wooden ramp was constructed.
Pigeon Key now became the headquarters for the
Road and Toll Bridge District. The bridge still required painting,
and the Moser Channel span still needed bridge tenders. In many
ways life went on as before; the island still served as a support
center for the Seven-Mile Bridge. Pigeon Key had a fishing camp
on it with a restaurant and bar in 1939 through early 1941. During
WW I and WW II, the bridges were guarded by the military.
In 1949, Brooks Bateman became manager of the
Road and Toll District; he and his family lived on Pigeon Key.
In 1953, due to the insistence of Representative Bernie Papy,
Monroe County residents could travel over U.S. 1 for free. In
1954, the road became toll-free for everyone, and the Road and
Toll Bridge District was dissolved. In the 1960s, the island became
a marine biology center for the University of Miami, and remained
so until 1987. At this time Monroe County, the owner of Pigeon
Key, began seeking a new role for the island. The Pigeon
Key Foundation was formed in 1993 in order to restore the
historic buildings, open the island to the public, provide educational
programs for youth and adults, and become a site for marine research
with Mote Marine Laboratory.